Disabled Nottingham man killed himself after his benefits were stopped by DWP-Atos ~ H.M. Coroner

Western Morning News

 

Please sign the War on Welfare (WoW) Petition and share: http://wowpetition.com/

Trusted article source icon

By Nottingham Post

Wednesday, October 09, 2013

By Dominic Howell

A 47-YEAR-OLD man overdosed on a cocktail of drugs after he had his benefits stopped because he was not given a proper medical assessment by the Department for Work and Pensions, an inquest heard.

Edward Jacques was found dead in his house in Loughborough Avenue, Sneinton, on September 25 last year. He had a history of self harm and depression, which stemmed from physical and emotional abuse as a child, the inquest was told.

 
Tragedy: Edward Jacques was found dead in his house in Sneinton, on September 25 last year. He had a history of self harm and depression.
Tragedy: Edward Jacques was found dead in his house in Sneinton, on September 25 last year. He had a history of self harm and depression.

 

Mr Jacques’ family told the Post they considered the decision to stop his benefits was a “major trigger” in a spiral which led him to overdose on heroin, cocaine and alcohol.

Mr Jacques was told his benefits of £90-a-week would be stopped on September 18 last year, the same day he took to social networking site Facebook to vent his frustration at Prime Minister David Cameron and Atos – the company which carries out medical assessments on behalf of the Department for Work and Pensions. 

The assessments determine whether a person is eligible for employment and support allowance.

After writing of his disapproval of the system he wrote on Facebook:

“It’s time to say goodbye, goodbye.”

At his inquest, which lasted two days, the court heard that Mr Jacques’ medical assessment took just 23 minutes and his allowance was stopped despite him suffering from HIV, hepatitis C, sciatica, severe depression, insomnia and dental pain.

The Nottinghamshire coroner, Miss Mairin Casey, branded it a “crude assessment”.

She said:

“I find the assessment process in Edward’s case did not fully or properly reflect Edward’s physical and mental health at that time.

“It is conceded by those involved in the [assessment] process that if the information as to Edward’s physical and mental health as shared by his GP had been known at the time of the assessment, the outcome would have been very different. It is desperately sad that such evidence was not available either to the nurse or to the decision maker.”

Mr Jacques’s GP at Sneinton Dale Surgery, Dr Prit Chahal, said that the assessor arrived at a conclusion which was “not in line with his professional view” of his patient.

Giving evidence on behalf of the Department for Work and Pensions, Jag Sanghera, said:

“The more evidence that is sought the easier the decision maker’s job.”

Mr Jacques’s elder brother, Richard Jacques, 58, and his twin sister Margaret Hudson, 48, said:

“We have no doubt that the decision to stop his allowance was a major trigger which led him on to a severe depression and desperate action.

“We do not believe that Edward is an isolated case and we think thousands of assessments have been made like this across the country.”

Miss Casey recorded a narrative verdict.

She said:

“Edward Jacques died as a result of central nervous system depression following a drug overdose and alcohol consumption. It is not possible for me to say if he intended that this action would result in his death.”

A DWP spokesman said:

“Our sympathy goes out to the family of Mr Jacques. A decision on whether someone is well enough to work is taken following a thorough assessment and after consideration of all supporting medical evidence from the claimant’s GP or medical specialist. The percentage of people entitled to employment and support allowance is now at its highest level with over half of people completing a work capability assessment eligible for the benefit.”

Nottingham Post

Weeks after his boy killed himself ~ Heartbroken dad reveals agony as decision to axe his son’s benefits is overturned Posted on October 6, 2013

 

38 thoughts on “Disabled Nottingham man killed himself after his benefits were stopped by DWP-Atos ~ H.M. Coroner

  1. Robert Chewter says:

    Thank you JJ for this I am battling with deniers on twitter atm claiming the benefit related deaths is just scaremongering and has no proof and just made up . This despite me being connected to a friend who attended funeral of someone who suicides following benefit fraud accusations .Are there any official stats on benefit related deaths please and can you post links to all these tragic stories on twitter as that would help too. Thanks I am wondering where all this denying is coming from of late all a bit worrying really .

  2. Robert Chewter says:

    Thank you JJ for this I am battling with deniers on twitter atm claiming the benefit related deaths is just scaremongering and has no proof and just made up . This despite me being connected to a friend who attended funeral of someone who suicides following benefit fraud accusations .Are there any official stats on benefit related deaths please and can you post links to all these tragic stories on twitter as that would help too. Thanks I am wondering where all this denying is coming from of late all a bit worrying really .

  3. Mark says:

    The comment of when will the persecution stop, I am figuring that it will stop when enough of us have ended up like Edward Jacques and saved the DWP £100 a week + Housing benefits / council tax for Cameron to meet his £500 million savings target…

  4. Robert Chewter says:

    @ann also when is the denying and twisting and dismissal of all these cases going to stop and who is producing all this discredit and denier stuff its pretty horrible I can tell you .I have screenshots of comments from denier dismissal lot and its pretty galling I can tell you.

  5. GEOFF REYNOLDS says:

    “ITS HARD TO BELIEVE AND TAKES A WHILE TO REALLY SINK IN,
    BUT THESE BASTARDS IN POWER, HAVE TAKEN THE LIVES OF MORE THAN 24 TIMES THE AMOUNT OF TROOPS KILLED IN IRAQ AND AFGHANISTAN”

    OVER 10600 PEOPLE HAVE DIED AT THE HANDS OF THIS CUT THROAT GOVERNMENT AND IT’S TWISTED POLICIES………

    NO WONDER THEY WANT TO TRY AND GAG THE PRESS AND THE BLOGGERS……………

    MURDER BY DECREE.

    “MAY YOU ROT AND BURN IN HELL”

    THIS WAS SOMEONES SON. YOU TOOK HIS LIFE AND LEFT HIS FAMILY AND FRIENDS, ABSOLUTELY DEVASTATED….

    THIS IS UNFORGIVABLE.

    HISTORY WILL REMEMBER YOU AS THE GOVERNMENT THAT MURDERED, TOTAL SCUM…………….

  6. GEOFF REYNOLDS says:

    “PLEASE BRING BACK HANGING”

    The list of volunteers to pull the lever on the trapdoor that saw you twitch and piss while your necks snapped, must be over a hundred miles long by now.

    Ignorance of the facts is no defence, especially when you are frantically trying to cover it up!

    “THE CHAINS ON THE GATES OF THE DWP CEMETERY OF SHAME ARE BUCKLING”………………………………………

    YOUR DEAD WILL COME BACK TO HAUNT YOU FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIVES…….

  7. Kathryne Wray (@gennydonne) says:

    It makes me ill every time I hear these tragic stories, but what makes me positively venomous is the cold and predictable DWP line at the end of every report:

    “Our sympathy goes out to the family of ‘X’….The percentage of people entitled to employment and support allowance is now at its highest level with over half of people completing a work capability assessment eligible for the benefit”.

    When is this social cleansing and culling of the poor, sick and vulnerable going to end?!?!

    1. JEFFREY says:

      that what i think typed aproved crap with no feeling at all
      they could not give a shit. jeff .. lph ..

  8. GEOFF REYNOLDS says:

    The government and all aspects of the media are complicit in the cover up of a campaign of murder against the weakest and most vulnerable in our society,

    GENOCIDE ON AN INDUSTRIAL SCALE NOT SEEN SINCE THE CONCENTRATION CAMPS WERE LIBERATED……………..

  9. GEOFF REYNOLDS says:

    “I WOULD WILLINGLY TAKE THE TWO HUNDRED QUID BELT THAT YOUR WIFE HAD ON AT THE TORY CONFERENCE, TIGHTEN IT AROUND YOUR NECK AND WATCH THE LAST BREATH ESCAPE YOUR LIPS”………………………….

    THEN DOUSE YOUR CORPSE WITH PETROL AND BURN YOUR BODY TO AN ASH PILE, SIMILAR TO THE LAST BASTARD WHO THOUGHT HE WAS INVINCIBLE………….

  10. nick says:

    “Criminal liability for complicity in another’s suicide. (1)A person who aids, abets, counsels or procures the suicide of another, or an attempt by another to commit suicide, shall be liable on conviction on indictment to imprisonment for a term not exceeding fourteen years. (2)If on the trial of an indictment for murder or manslaughter it is proved that the accused aided, abetted, counselled or procured the suicide of the person in question, the jury may find him guilty of that offence.”

  11. Steven Goodman says:

    Unfortunately its the sad reality of a system hijacked by a hidden (rightwing) agenda to relise a negative result and socail impact on the weakest members of society. Its class warfare being waged by economic fascists, who I prefer to call the “unholy Tory Trinity” for collectively their achievements can seriously compete with “the angel of death”.

    The one aspect I find most distasteful is Ducan Smith’s glee at the effects his reforms are having (Death rate from suicide 72 per week in 2012 now increased to 104 a week in 2013)…He is an imbecile when it comes to having eithier emotional intelligence or a sense of moralistic guilt – he strikes me as the nasty little kid who pulls the legs off of spiders just to see it suffer from the inflicted handicap…….Sadly the disabled people who are retreating into a dark place where they kill themselves, aren’t the ones who are trying to affect or control a mental disorder. It will be the ones who largely cannot look after themselves and totally unprepared for the vicious attack a medical examination by Atos represents…nor the complete dis-regard for their “duty of Care” responsibility of the DWP, who by all accounts are recieving advice from a American Insurance corporation which has been labelled “Criminalistic” and “Totally immoral” by their own government for tactics used to avoid policy payouts and these are the people who want to destroy welfare’s protection remit and privatise Unemployment provision with policies they intend to sell to the working public who have aided the government (By benefit scrounger, disabled hate speak) in enslaving themselves to a company who intends to charge a damn sight more than your national insurance contribution and thus entitlement to supportive welfare costs…reference privatisations so far Communications, power supply, public transport, water, ect…..I challenge you to highlight any of them that has rewarded the public in terms of lowering prices or improving services? by looking to the past, you can easily predict the future in regards to welfare!

    As to Cameron, why would he enguage with a criminal corporation and assign them to advising the DWP on how to abuse their client base, to whom they owe a duty of care. If it wasn’t likely to be something like a decent “Party Contribution” that had an excessive amount of 0000000’s after it?

  12. lee jackson says:

    i was assessed by atos in 2011,i was awarded zero points,i complained to atos stating their assessor was not qualified enough to understand the conditions i suffer from. atos replied admitting they assessed me incorrectly,im waiting to see what the dwp do with me now.even though the dwp reconsidered my case several times themselves,but each time turning me down.i went to appeal and won my case for esa,but all this took 2 years of fighting,very mentally draining and very frustrating,and i fully sympathise with people who were crushed by the unsympathetic actions of atos and the dwp.

    1. PAUL says:

      i’m going to my tribunal this month..
      after waiting over a year in total taking into account the atos… so called medical…in 2012… its like i have had a year of my life frozen…can you tell me if i dont win this appeal… can i take it to a higher tribunal? or must i re-apply for esa?

  13. Andrew Walker says:

    Nick, the law cannot support I am afraid what your getting at. If you read the statute it is really about a person helping someone else commit suicide, not about who may have inadvertantly caused it. If that was the case every bastard person who drove someone to suicide would be locked up. Over the years there would have been hundreds of thousands of them.

    1. Andrew Walker says:

      I use inadvertently with caution, and i hope you get my drift. This government it seems, is driving people to suicide. They could never be found to have criminal liability under that act. Ps I am one of the people under review.

  14. Samuel Miller says:

    I will inform senior UN officials about this tragic suicide. We should also consider petitioning Mr. Keir Starmer, QC, Director of Public Prosecutions, and recommend that his office, as well as law enforcement agencies in the United Kingdom, investigate whether criminal charges should be filed against Atos Healthcare UK under various legislative acts, including the Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007.

    The DWP and its ministers should, as well, be criminally investigated since they supervise the Atos contract and created the descriptors which Atos employs in its assessments.

    There have been recent suicides and suicide attempts related to the draconian welfare reforms. The crisis for Britain’s sick and disabled is worsening and we must take immediate action.

    “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.”
    ― Edmund Burke

  15. PAUL says:

    same old rhetoric from dwp henchmen…its unbearable …this government has to be driven out of office…forceably. and now…

  16. geoff reynolds says:

    I have said it lots of times and i will repeat it again, BILL GUNNYEON is the chief medical officer of the DWP..

    Each and every death that occurs on his watch has had his official blessing.

    He is employed by the DWP to make sure that the policies that they carry out are safe to the general public.

    Notwithstanding this, the man is a prime elected murderer, specially selected for his links to the health insurance industry.

    He is the “ANGEL OF DEATH”, the governments own, Josef Mengele, the Nazi SS people exterminator and crazed doctor of Auschwitz.

    The government has carefully utilised a handful of traitors to initiate these inhumane acts on the disabled, poor and weak.
    ……………………………………………………………………………….

    To: Mr G Reynolds
    DWP Central Freedom of Information Team

    e-mail: [DWP request email]

    Our Ref: VTR 1785

    29 April 2013

    Dear Mr Reynolds,

    Freedom of Information Act – Request for Information
    Our Reference: FoI 1785

    Thank you for your Freedom of Information request which we received on 15 April 2013.

    You asked:

    You recently quoted the following paragraph in a FOI response;

    ‘The assisted text phrases that may be used to construct the medical history were drawn from
    many sources including the Incapacity Benefit Handbook, medical text books, examples of high
    quality Personal Capability Assessment report and discussions with experienced approved
    Healthcare Professionals (HCP). They have been quality assured by panels of experienced
    HCPs and deemed appropriate for constructing good quality relevant clinical and functional
    histories and were agreed in consultation with the DWP Health and Benefits Division (formerly
    Corporate Medical Group).

    COULD YOU STATE, CATEGORICALLY, THAN UNUM CORPORATION HAD NO
    INFLUENCE IN THE CONSTRUCTION OF LIMA BASES BIOPSYCHOSOCIAL
    SOFTWARE USED IN ESA EXAMINATIONS?

    DID MEMBERS OF THE INSURANCE INDUSTRY HAVE INPUT INTO THE
    CONSTRUCTION OF THE LIMA SOFTWARE THAT IS USED DURING AN ESA
    EXAMINATION?

    DID MANSEL AYLWARD HAVE LINKS TO THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE SOFTWARE.
    IF SO PLEASE STATE, AND DESCRIBE HIS INPUT’?

    In response, I can advise that neither the Department nor Atos Healthcare hold any
    documentation that links the LiMA software, used for Work Capability Assessments, with Unum,
    the insurance industry or Mansel Aylward.
    If you have any queries about this letter please contact me quoting the reference number
    above.

    Yours sincerely

    Business Management Team
    Health & Disability Assessments (Operations)
    [email address]
    ………………………………………………………………………………

    U n u m corporations failure to record a conflict of interest.

    GEOFFREY REYNOLDS (Account suspended) made this Freedom of Information request to Department for Work and Pensions

    The request was refused by Department for Work and Pensions.
    From: GEOFFREY REYNOLDS (Account suspended)

    22 December 2012

    Dear Department for Work and Pensions,
    1.Have executives of U N U M corporation sat on mental or physical,
    technical working groups on behalf of any British government?

    2.Have executives or staff, from either U N U M, or A T O S, acted
    in steering any favourable decisions for contracts for themselves?

    3.Have A T O S, who funded the Biopsychosocial Research department
    at Cardiff University, now distanced themselves from this
    department?

    4.Does the department above, still do classes and accreditation for
    A T O S HCP personnel?

    5.Could this cosy relationship be defined as a “Conflict of
    interest” that is clearly apparent, blatant and reprehensible,
    given the magnitude of the effects of their policies inflicted on
    the disabled?

    Link to this
    From: DWP freedom-of-information-requests
    Department for Work and Pensions

    22 December 2012

    This is an automated confirmation that your request for information has
    been accepted by the DWP FoI mailbox.

    By the next working day your request will be forwarded to the relevant
    information owner within the Department who will respond to you direct.

    If your email is a Freedom of Information request you can normally
    expect a response within 20 working days.

    Should you have any further queries in connection with this request do
    please contact us.

    For further information on the Freedom of Information Act within DWP
    please click on the link below.

    [1]http://www.dwp.gov.uk/freedom-of-informa…

    show quoted sections

    References

    Visible links
    1. http://www.dwp.gov.uk/freedom-of-informa

    Link to this
    From: DWP DWP Medical Services Correspondence
    Department for Work and Pensions

    24 January 2013

    Attachment FOI 5116 Mr Reynolds Response.pdf
    12K Download View as HTML

    Dear Mr Reynolds

    Please see your FOI response attached

    Kind regards

    Health & Disability Assessments (Operations)/Department for Work and Pensions/Room 306/Block 31/Norcross/Norcross Lane/Blackpool/FY5 3TA

    show quoted sections

    Link to this
    GEOFFREY REYNOLDS (Account suspended) left an annotation (24 January 2013)

    Lord Kirkwood of Kirkhope

    A previous Chair of the Parliamentary Select Committee on Work and Pensions, Lord Kirkwood of Kirkhope, is listed in the House of Lords Register of Interests (Session 2006-2007) as the Chairman of the Unum Customer Advisory Panel for which he received payment from Unum and additional payments for other work for Unum.

    Link to this
    GEOFFREY REYNOLDS (Account suspended) left an annotation (24 January 2013)

    Chris Grayling: The work capability assessment was developed in 2008 with the assistance of technical working groups. As you may be aware, the Government consult widely with stakeholders and sources of public and private sector expertise, to ensure that its policies are evidence-based. Two Unum employees, a doctor and an occupational therapist, were invited to join the technical working group that carried out the review of the personal capability assessment. As with all members of the technical working group they were appointed as recognised experts in benefit assessment and in supporting return to work for people with disability.

    I can confirm that since the initial review of the personal capability assessment as part of the technical working groups, that representatives of the company, Unum, have not been involved in either the administration or review of the work capability assessment.

    The Department of Work and Pension has also not engaged with Unum in the design or administration of the appeals process.

    Link to this
    Dan Manville left an annotation (25 January 2013)

    I would suggest an application for the minutes of the Physical Function and Mental Health Technical Working Groups for the “Transformation of the Personal Capability Assessment” project that first reported in September 2006 might be valuable.

    http://www.dwp.gov.uk/docs/tpca.pdf

    Is a start…

    Link to this
    GEOFFREY REYNOLDS (Account suspended) left an annotation (26 January 2013)

    Extracts from the Report of the Physical Function and Mental Health Technical Working Groups.
    Commissioned by DWP sept 2006.

    There is still work to be done,to test the proposed new assignment in a live environment. This will be done by asking ATOS MEDICAL SERVICES DOCTORS to complete a PCA on incapacity benefit claimants.

    Among the experts cited at being present at the meeting;

    Sue Godby-UNUM PROVIDENT
    Dr Angela Graham-ATOS ORIGIN
    Dr Paul Stidolph-DWP
    Ann Spaight-Chair of DISABILITY ALLOWANCE ADVISORY BOARD
    Dr Peter Dewis-UNUM PROVIDENT
    ……………………………………………………………………………….

    Geoffrey .. Dig deep into the Faculty of Occupational Medicine (registered as an independent charity) and you will find that they too are a member of the same Atos family along with their partner the Royal College of Physicians of which the FOM is a faculty member of, and living rent free in the same accommodation.. By both groups distancing themselves and pertaining to be a different organisation from Atos/Unum they can gain additional seats on government advisory panels, give support to policies, and be additionally consulted on new legislation to give strength to the intended changes., all whilst being part of that same group.

    In 2009 the FOM held their 30th Anniversary celebration at the House of Lords supported by their sponsors Serco and Atos Healthcare..

    Occupational health services serving more than 1,000,000 Government and private employees had achieved SEQOHS accreditation by October 2012. this is managed by the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) on behalf of the Faculty of Occupational Medicine (FOM). Staff working for some of the country’s biggest employers are receiving occupational health advice and support from accredited services; this includes 1,000,000 staff looked after by ATOS healthcare. A hint came from Cameron when he said “We are all in it together.”.
    ……………………………………………………………………………..

    The Guardian, Wednesday 12 September 2012 21.00 BST

    This week the sixth International Forum on Disability Management, IFDM 2012, takes place at Imperial College London. It is sponsored by some of the world’s largest medical insurance companies, Unum among them, and speakers include DWP chief medical adviser Dr Bill Gunyeon and Professor Sir Mansel Aylward, formerly DWP chief medical adviser and director of the Centre for Psychosocial and Disability Research at Cardiff University, which was sponsored by Unum from its inception in 2003 until 2009.

    Unum’s website states that during this sponsorship period “a series of papers was published, identifying the range of factors that determine why some people become long-term absentees”. The Cardiff papers advocated a “biopsychosocial model” of disability which Unum says “informed its approach to medical underwriting”. It is the same approach upon which the current Atos work capability assessment (WCA) is based. Concomitantly, the company were advising the UK government on welfare reform.

    ………………………………………………………………………………

    Sadly, guess who is the independent scrutineer for ATOS,

    The one and only PAUL LITCHFIELD…..

    Labour partys ASSESSMENT IN MENTAL HEALTH TECHNICAL WORKING GROUP….

    Sue Godby, UnumUK
    Dr Angela Gra­ham, Atos Origin
    Dr Paul Litch­field, Fac­ulty of Occu­pa­tional Medi­cine (Bill Gunnyeon, now the chief Med­ical Advisor to DWP was the pres­id­ent of the FOM)

    In Phys­ical Tech­nical Work­ing Group included:

    Dr Angela Gra­ham, Atos Ori­gin Med­ical Services
    Dr Peter Dewis, Dis­ab­il­ity Ana­lyst and Cus­tomer Care Dir­ector, UnumUK
    Dr David Hende­r­son Slater, yet again

    The former Chief Med­ical Advisor to the UK gov­ern­ment, Pro­fessor Mansel Ayl­ward, was instru­mental in advising the UK gov­ern­ment to set up med­ical assess­ment centres based on the model in Amer­ica, and he is still fun­ded by the same Amer­ican com­pany used in his example, with his research centre in Wales. The company’s name: UnumProvid­ent (UK). Indeed, his research centre for Psychoso­cial and Dis­ab­il­ity Research is based at Cardiff Uni­ver­sity (Pro­fessor Ayl­ward is the Dir­ector) is named the“UnumProvident Centre.” Pro­fessor Ayl­ward was also instru­mental in how the recent Wel­fare Reform Act was to be imple­men­ted by the DWP. 8

    ATOS AND ITS TWISTED CHILDREN….

    ………………………………………………………………………………

    Thank you for your email dated 21 March 2013 requesting a review of the Department for
    Work and Pensions (DWP) response to your Freedom of Information request (FoI 1141) dated
    8 March 2013.

    In your email you asked to be provided with information answering the following questions:-

    I am writing to request an internal review of Department for Work and Pensions’s handling of
    my FOI request ‘”Bouncing Bill’s Circus of Death and Despair”‘.
    Given that the contract between DWP and ATOS has been kept secret from the public, the
    percentage of examination failures is astronomic, one must come to a conclusion that
    wrongdoing is apparent.

    Disability benefits are being stolen from claimants due to pressure from within your
    organisation.

    Bill Gunnyeon is mandating deprivation and death of those most weakest in society, a form of
    Ethnic Cleansing, in breach of the Human Rights Act, i therefore request an internal review.

    Please be assured that your request has been given our full consideration and that all aspects
    of your review were taken fully into account.

    The review was conducted by an independent official of the Department, of the relevant grade
    and authority to carry out such requests. The case has been examined afresh, and guidance
    has been sought from domain experts to ensure all factors were taken fully into account

    In your request, FoI 1141, you asked for the percentage of claimants that ATOS were
    instructed to fail to deprive them of their disability benefits. The response explained that Atos
    Healthcare do not have targets to reduce the number of claimants on benefit, it also explained
    that they do not have any role in the benefit decision making process.

    I can further add that FoI is about supplying recorded information held by the Department; it is
    not to explain things or confirm whether your assumptions are correct or not.

    MY ASSUMPTIONS ARE CORRECT AND THE DEPARTMENT IS LYING (FACT NOT FICTION)
    GUNNYEONS TRAIL OF DEATH CONTINUES……….

    ………………………………………………………………………………

    ………………..and as we speak, the mortuaries lay claim to the never ending queue of government sponsored murders…

    THIS DEATH HAPPENED A YEAR AGO, HOW MANY MORE WILL COME TO LIGHT?

  17. jed goodright says:

    I’ve copied this to Rachel Reeves but don’t expect any reply. I’ve copied it to the SG at the UN and again don’t expect any reply. It looks to me that global capitalism can do what it likes with whoever it wants and the rich boys will not stand against it.

  18. Andy Pandy says:

    My thoughts go out to the family and friends of Mr. Jacques.
    Yet another tragic statistic showing that the u.k. Government and its policy makers are either that far removed from reality or a scheming bunch of narcissitic sociopaths. I reckon that every one of these tragedies amounts to a hate crime and the perpetrators
    should all be brought before the courts and made accountable for their crimes against humanity.

  19. Robert Chewter says:

    @JJ and BTC deniers getting worse by the minute now demanding coroners reports !! Are these ppl for real ??

  20. Robert Chewter says:

    Hey all on this thread just who are these sick deniers and disinfo mob ?? Demanding coroners reports as proof as I am ‘ scaremongering’ and ‘ making wild claims ‘ jeez wtf is going on guys ?? Someone tell me please

  21. PAULA says:

    THE ONE AND ONLY PERSON RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL THESE DEATHS AND SUICIDES BY SIGNING THE WELFARE REFORM ACT IS OUR BELOVED QUEEN, BLESS HER, DIANA WILL ALWAYS HAUNT YOU, EVIL WITCH!

    1. geoff reynolds says:

      When will the fat idle bastard, that does nothing more than shake hands,go on holiday and sample the best of everything, rescind the welfare reform acts.
      ……..maybe she’s too busy patting the corgi’s and unveiling plaques to herself, than to look out of her palatial windows to see the death and despair she gave her backing to……

      The Royal Family, the most privileged welfare scroungers that this country has ever seen.

      Fuck you jack, i’m alright…………

      WHY DON’T YOU GIVE US CAKE?

      1. David says:

        As you may or may not know the Crown of Great Britain no longer has any legal power at all to remove laws or governments, or to interfere with the running of this country. You have Oliver Cromwell who instigated the elections of MPs to the houses of parliament.

  22. ali says:

    Its a crying shame, atos and this government dont care about the sick or disabled people, I dont know how they expect people to work when they have an illness, they wont stop until there is no beneft system or nhs, the government want to get rid of both of these. Atos assesments are not carried out by specialist consultants and how can they make a decision when they dont know how people live and suffer with there illness or disability day in day out, in pain every day. They aint got a clue, all they are interested is getting everyone in to work, there arnt any jobs, and thats another thing they want people to work for nothing. They dont live in the real world. How can someone go for an assessment and get a decision back in less than a week.
    People with medical evidence should be left alone.
    Rest In Peace Edward. God Bless

  23. GEOFF REYNOLDS says:

    “CHILL OUT”

    I am looking forward to Christmas in the same way a turkey is………
    Glad tidings of great joy i bring, what a load of crap!

    One of my friends came round this morning and helped to remove two panels out of my fence. These two panels represent my heating over the winter period, maybe the rest will have to come down.
    Being disabled brings all the merits of a civilised society, especially a disability for life, what i had till having it stolen from me by a terminator, EMMA BRODRICK, an ATOS terminator.
    First they took my Incapacity Benefit then came and took my Disability Living Allowance.

    The DWP say that they can do this as my circumstances have changed. I have never reported a change, only the ATOS report……………..
    My circumstances have changed, “THEY STOLE MY BENEFITS”

    Originally my benefits were awarded at a medical tribunal following an accident at work. The tribunal was attended by two doctors, each having a raft of qualifications after their names, the ATOS nurse had done a short course……………
    They have no qualifications that any of the medical councils recognise……..

    The doors are beginning to stick due to the damp in the air, winter is on its way. Nevertheless my family will manage. We have to, its not a matter of choice.
    We have not lit our gas fire for a long time now, indeed this will be our fourth year without heat. I explained this to my ATOS nurse but she must have forgot to put it on my biased report.
    Strange it being omitted?

    Mind you, she will be celebrating in style with the wages of sin she has amassed. I wonder if any of her clients have died?

    Christmas last year was a time to celebrate, we had a meagre benefit then, this year will be a trial to stay alive.

    The pieces of wood from my fence will be burnt in the flue area that used to be occupied by my gasfire, an ornament from the good days. There is an old flagstone on what is left of the carpet, directly below my little fire. It should stop a lot of the sparks.
    Going to the toilet is fun, you have to use the lit candle to maneouvre your way there, cannot afford to use the electric.

    Ice forms on the inside of your doors and windows but the old coats thrown on the bed help keep the hypothermia at bay.

    Hypothermia, apparently is a good way to die, you don’t realise your life is being taken away, similar to the actions of the DWP………………..

    My son goes to a sixth form college now, the bus fare is a pound each wayor one meal less, as we see it. We feed him best we can but his friends, whose parents are not shirkers, give him their leftovers……….

    Christmas dinner will be an anticlimax. You can hardly don party hats and celebrate.
    As the privileged watch giant plasma screens and scramble to open presents, we will be huddling to keep warm, weighted by our old fleeces,whilst keeping an eye on the thermometer.
    Any food we get will have been given by a good samaritan.
    Our son realises that we love him so much, even though we can’t afford to buy him any gifts. His gift is the gift of life…………..

    As the government turn a blind eye to the energy companies obscene act of raising profits for the bosses and shareholders, the old pass away in droves. It will not bother any ministers either, their expenses will suffice nicely to enable a sugar coated festivity.

    The government rhetoric about impressing upon the energy companies to show their lowest tariffs, is no good to the people who cannot afford energy.
    The only warmth they will feel is the giant gas flames engulfing their bodies in the the crematorium…………………………

    Talking of crematoriums, why haven’t the coalition brought these in yet, they have introduced all the other doctrines of the NAZIS against the weakest and most vulnerable.

    “AS THE BOTTLES OF BUBBLY ARE POPPING IN THE CAPITAL, THE REST OF THE COUNTRY WILL BE POPPING THEIR CLOGS”

  24. Humanity2012 says:

    This Country has been a State of Bloody Hell since the Con Dem
    Pratts came to Power upon the 11th of May 2010 and Shame
    Shame Shame upon the ” Official Opposition ” for being A
    Bunch of Zombie Dummies

    Welfare has been Messed With the Bloodbath in Afghanistan has
    been Diabolical and the Poor Stolen From

    Screw the Profits of Big Business and Sack from Office Rich
    People’s Party Politicians

  25. PAULA says:

    IF ANY MEMBER OF MY FAMILY DIED THROUGH HAVING THEIR BENEFITS STOPPED,THE F’IN RAGE WOULD MAKE ME GO AFTER THE BASTARDS WITH A MACHETEE, I WOULD CHOP AS MANY OF THEM BASTARD POLITICIANS AS I COULD, THEY WOULD HAVE TO SHOOT ME DEAD TO MAKE ME STOP, WHAT A PERFECT WAY IT WOULD BE TO LEAVE THIS LIFE!

  26. charlene mason says:

    This is a COLOSSAL tragedy, poor Mr. Jacques. I wished I could have conversed with him before this heartbreaking tragedy; simply to let him know that he was NOT ALONE trapped inside this EVIL WEB of government CORRUPTION. I am WITHOUT BENEFITS TOO. I do NOT have a source of income as the EVIL TORY NAZI government have unleashed the DEVIL upon their own people. I am worried where my NEXT MEAL is coming from. I want Cameron out of office NOW. He makes me ashamed to be British. This EVILNESS upon the British people should NOT be happening in the 21st CENTURY. I despise Cameron’s NAZI government.

  27. charlene mason says:

    The lying, evil, corrupt DWP simply told me that they want me dead in order for them to SAVE MONEY. I have a long term depressional illness and I intend to fight them legally through the law courts. The CALLOUS DWP has NO SYMPATHY for anyone.

Leave a Reply